This year I have personally put together and painted the trophies for Best General and Best Paint and thought I would share what you might be striving for in your efforts to prepare for the tournament.
First off we have the Best Paint Trophy. The original sculpt is from MOM Miniaturas, with a slight modification from me where I cut off the warhammer and replaced it with a brush I sculpted from green stuff:
In order to win Best Paint, players will compete with the appearance of their army in several categories. We will be following the same rubric as last year, as this seemed to work best.
Each player will fill out their own paint score sheet during the first day of the tournament and will
answer a series of questions worth a certain amount of points. Then, after the player has filled
this out, a paint judge will assign their army a certain amount of additional points based off of
their own personal discretion. Usually this will extend to how cool the theme of the army is,
technical execution (i.e. Object Source Lighting or Non-Metallic Metals, things of that nature).
All of this will be written down to tabulate the overall paint score for that player.
Therefore the player is largely responsible for their own score and can give themselves up to
25 points with the paint judge being responsible for another 15 to calculate your overall paint
score (1-40 points). The player score is broken down as follows:
1. Is the whole army painted to a 3 color minimum? (1-5 points)
2. Does the army have a consistent basing scheme? (1-3 points)
3. Does the army have a consistent paint scheme? (1-3 points)
4. Are the models consistently shaded and highlighted? If so, explain how: (1-3 points)
5. Are there noticeable conversions on any of your units? Please explain any
conversions: (1-5 points)
6. Does the army have a matching display board? A name placard? Is the display dynamic
and themed? (1 point for each question for a total of 3 points possible)
7. Does the army theme extend beyond painting to include modeling, basing, and unit selection?
If so please explain how these goals were met: (1-3 points)
The paint judge then has 15 additional points he can award to any army, but that generally focus
around things like:
Advanced techniques utilized: 1-5 points
Storytelling in display (does your army look like it has a story behind it? Or is it a generic
goblin/ogre/dwarf army?) 1-5 points
Overall appearance (does your army look cohesive, dynamic, or is it cool to be seen on
the tabletop?) 1-4 points
Judge's choice (Only one army can receive this in the entire tournament) 1 point
Next up we have the Best General Award. It's a bigger trophy, as befits the ego and accomplishment of the one who will be taking it home:
That should do us for this time. Let me know what you think of these trophies in the comments below and I look forward to seeing you in October and rolling some dice with you!